Improvisation in Dog Training and Life in General

November 20th, 2009 by Neil

One of our basic human needs is stability.  Sure we learn, and we grow – that’s happening all the time.  And it’s good to take some time to process new knowledge and skill, to feel like you really OWN the material.  But it can be all too easy to hang out in your comfort zone for too long.  When you’re training your dogs (or training yourself, for that matter), you have to honor another paradoxical need: Variety.

I’ve received several e-mails from those of you who are working with the DVD set (Natural Dog Training: The Fundamentals) that have reminded me of this issue.  The first DVD is a thorough treatment of how to do the pushing exercise, how to rechannel your dog’s energy with redirection, and how to use Tug-of-War and Fetchtug to reinforce your mooseness in your dog’s eyes – along with lots of information about the hows and whys.  I’ve been hearing stories of amazing changes in your relationship with your dog, just working on these exercises alone.  And I know that pretty much everywhere I say that the key to your success is to be gradual, be gradual.

What does it mean to be gradual in your approach to dog training?

When I talk about being gradual, what I really mean is that you shouldn’t try to do everything all at once.  That you should take your time, gaining familiarity with the techniques, owning them in your muscle memory, letting the work that you’re doing with your dog register with the way that you feel.  While the mechanics are certainly important, the new awareness of your dog’s interactions with the world and your interactions with your dog are the true nuggets of understanding that will carry you through all levels of the training.  So when I talk about being gradual, I’m talking about going easy on yourself and your dog, feeling free to take time with the material, and soaking it up into the fabric of your experience.

That being said, you should resist the temptation to give into your need for stability, which can trend towards perfectionism.  You don’t have to have everything “perfect” before you move onto the next technique.  Your dog doesn’t have to have the hardest push in the world before you start working on heeling, or sit/stay/down.  As you start to feel like you “get” what you’re doing on an intuitive level, even if you haven’t “mastered” it – that’s a sign that you should try something new.

I know, I know – I made TWO DVDs.  And one is called “The Basics” and the other one is called “Mastering Obedience”.  Surely you need to perfect every basic technique before you’re ready to master obedience, right?  Wrong!!!

Remember that “obedience” work is not separate from becoming the moose.  It is PART of becoming the moose.

When you use basic techniques to put your dog into the right emotional state, obedience behaviors flow naturally as long as you know how to elicit them.  That’s what the second DVD is all about (and the writing on this site about, for instance, box work – Sit, Down, Stay).  The DVDs also cover heeling, which so far I haven’t written about in any detail on this site.  Now that you know how to elicit your dog’s attraction, how to work WITH your dog’s emotional energy – in fact how to attract it, then you are ready to start working on the obedience techniques that I talk about here on this site and on DVD #2.

As you work through THOSE exercises they will also reinforce your mooseness, because your dog will be responding to you in a way that honors the deepest forces in their emotional makeup.  When you taught your dog to sit BEFORE they might have experienced it as an interruption of the flow, but this different way of teaching sit will actually increase your dog’s flow and attraction to you.  And since basic techniques like pushing and tug free up a lot of energy in your dog, by working on obedience you are actually reminding your dog of the best ways for them to channel their energized attraction to you.  In this context, being “obedient” actually helps resolve the energy within them.

Plus, variety really is the spice of life

In order to keep moving, to keep growing, and to keep your dog engaged in the process, you have to fill your need for variety as well.  As you learn more and more of the techniques, you will feel comfortable enough to  improvise during the time that you spend with your dog.  This improvisation will teach you how to switch fluidly, in the moment, from one technique to the next, until they just become “the way” that you interact with your dog.  At that point, you start to forget that there are “techniques” per se, and “obedience” – you just have a relationship, with all the natural give and take of any successful relationship.  You won’t get there tomorrow – and that’s what “being gradual” is all about.  But please, feel free to embark on that journey TODAY.

After all, the variety will keep things fun for both you and your dog.  And if it ain’t fun, what’s the point?  Actually, let me rephrase that.  If you can’t MAKE it fun, then what’s the point?

All my best to you and your dogs.

Zella Smiles At You

Zella Smiles At You


Did you find this article to be helpful? Would you like more information about how to transform your relationship with your dog (and your dog's relationship with the world)? Please subscribe to my e-mail newletter for quick tips, exclusive content, and...discounts on merchandise!

For Email Newsletters you can trust




Related Articles



Dog Training: A Training Plan for You

November 21st, 2007 by Neil

Having covered lots of training ground, I thought this might be a good time to talk about a structure for your training sessions.  With a proper training plan you can cover all of the bases in a relatively short amount of time:  working on obedience, addressing any problems you might be having, and giving your dog a healthy amount of exercise (both physical and emotional).  In case you were wondering how it all fits together, my goal for this article is to give you a clear picture of what a typical training session might look like for you and your dog.  Plus, with the holiday weekend coming up (it’s Thanksgiving week here in the U.S.) you’re going to have lots of time to focus on training with your dog, right?!?

A Typical Session of Natural Dog Training:  First things first

  1. Prepare.  Preparations involve having tasty treats in an easy-to-access pouch, your long training leash, and whatever other equipment you think you’re going to need (tug toys, training box, flat or prong collar, etc.).
  2. Time.  Since I generally use food during training sessions, I like to train dogs around mealtimes.  If you can spend 20 minutes in the morning and 20 minutes in the evening of focused training time with your dog, you’ll have a happy dog on the route to being well-trained.  Any additional time is bonus (like if you’re taking your dog along for a jog, for instance).
  3. Assess.  Take your dog outside.  Remember that almost all training (except for those things specifically designed to happen inside) should happen outside.  Think about how your dog has been lately.  Have there been any notable improvements?  Any obstacles?  Do you feel like you’re getting 100% of your dog’s energy yet, or is your dog still holding back?  How much energy can your dog handle while staying relaxed, and at what point does your dog tense up?  And how about you – have you been able to stay calm while working with your dog and helping your dog interact with the world?  Are you remembering to check in with yourself while you train?  And have you been able to focus, non-judgementally, on your dog’s experience, to seize moments of opportunity as you’re out in the world?

“Formal” Training time – play with it to get something that works for you

  1. Play fetchtugI’ll start with tug-of-war, and then I’ll transition to fetchtug.  The goal is to just get your dog’s energy flowing.  Intersperse fetchtug with encouraging your dog to chase you around as much as possible.  You can also toss out a surprise treat here and there, to keep it even more engaging.  After about 5 minutes (tops) you’ll want to transition to
  2. Pushing.  You can learn how to push from this article.  You can learn why to push from this article.  Spend about 5 minutes on pushing with your dog, starting with smaller pushes, and gradually building up to your dog’s threshold for pushing.  REMEMBER NOT TO EXCEED YOUR DOG’S THRESHOLD.  It’s just like lifting weights – use the largest weight (push) you can without injuring yourself (pushing so hard that your dog backs away from you).  Over time your dog’s ability to push will increase.
  3. Box-work.  Spend another 5 minutes doing work on and off the box.  At this point we’ve covered “sit” and a low intensity “stay” on the box, along with using pushing to get your dog off the box.  I’ll add links to other box techniques as we cover them on the blog.
  4. Cool down.  Now it’s time to help your dog get as relaxed as possible.  Spend your last 5 minutes massaging your dog.  Stay quiet, and see if you can get YOURSELF into a relaxed, meditative state while you work on removing all the physical tension from your dog’s body with gentle touch.  You are your dog’s massage therapist – make sure your touch is relaxing and not stimulating.
  5. Head inside – you’re done!

Training “in the field”

Assuming that you’re going to take your dog on at least one walk per day, make sure that you’re familiar with the exercise on how to redirect an excited or aggressive dog, and use it to reinforce your “moose-ness” in your dog’s eyes as you walk around the neighborhood.

Specialized work

If you have problems that you’re working on, you can find specialized exercises on this blog (try the solving problems category for starters).  You can work those exercises into your daily training sessions, or you can set up special times, when it’s convenient for you, to work on those exercises.  The important thing is for you to ensure that you have the proper time to focus on the work that you’re going to do with your dog, and, especially after the specialized exercises, to make sure that you have time to help your dog relax, through tug of war and massage (along with the other techniques we’ve discussed), at the end of your session.

I hope that this has given you a good start on a structure for how to work Natural Dog Training into your life with your dog.  As I add new exercises on the blog, we’ll discuss how they can be incorporated into your existing routine.  Remember, it’s not the quantity of time that matters – it’s the quality!  Think about your training plan, create a structure for yourself (and your dog), and do your best to stick to it consistently.  Your dog will be very grateful, and you’ll notice a constant evolution in your progress together.

And speaking of gratitude – thank you to all of you who are visiting the NaturalDogBlog.  I appreciate your feedback, questions, and participation in making this one of the most informative (and practical) Natural Dog Training sites on the web.  You’ve helped to make my first few blogging-full-time months really fantastic, and I am most appreciative.


Did you find this article to be helpful? Would you like more information about how to transform your relationship with your dog (and your dog's relationship with the world)? Please subscribe to my e-mail newletter for quick tips, exclusive content, and...discounts on merchandise!

For Email Newsletters you can trust




Related Articles